Tire Implementation: Comprehensive Critical Review

Executive Summary

Overall Grade: B+ (85%)

The tire implementation is functionally solid but has room for improvement in:

Production deployment (critical blocker)
React Query migration (performance)
Test coverage (quality)
Autocomplete integration (UX)

What Was Done Well ✅

Frontend (CROP-front)

Area	Implementation	Grade
Slug Migration	Redirect from `kmt-` → `ct-kmt-` with fallback	A
SEO Metadata	OpenGraph, Twitter cards implemented	A
Loading States	Skeleton UI with `loading.tsx`	A
Error Handling	`error.tsx` with retry button	A
Not Found Page	Clean `not-found.tsx`	A
Performance	React.memo on TireCard/TiresGrid	A
Accessibility	Semantic `<section>` with aria-label	A
Constants	Centralized TIRE_MANUFACTURER	A
Type Safety	Comprehensive Tire type definitions	A

Backend (CROP-parts-services)

Area	Implementation	Grade
Index Resolver	Multi-index routing for KMT	A
Search Endpoint	Uses `resolveSearchIndex()`	A
Filters Endpoint	Uses `resolveSearchIndex()`	A
Parts Endpoint	Uses `getAllSearchIndices()`	A
Equipment Endpoint	Uses `getAllSearchIndices()`	A

What Needs Improvement ⚠️

1. CRITICAL: Deployment Not Done

Status: Search service with multi-index fix is NOT deployed

# Current deployed version:
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/ready' | jq '.revision'
# → "search-service-00310-mrr"

# Code has fix but not deployed (commit 77744e8)

Impact: Tire pages show "Tire not found" because /api/parts/:id only searches parts_current

Fix:

gcloud run deploy search-service \
  --source . \
  --region us-east1 \
  --project noted-bliss-466410-q6

2. HIGH: ES Tire Index Has Old Slugs

Status: ES index uses kmt-* but MongoDB/frontend expects ct-kmt-*

# Current ES slugs:
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/api/search?manufacturer=KMT&limit=1' | jq '.parts[0].slug'
# → "kmt-04493560000" (OLD format)

# Expected:
# → "ct-kmt-04493560000" (NEW format)

Fix:

bash services/search/scripts/gcp-rebuild-tires-index.sh

3. MEDIUM: Autocomplete Ignores Tire Index

File: services/search/src/routes/autocomplete.ts Lines: 366, 460, 488

// PROBLEM: Enhanced mode hardcodes parts index
indexName: env.SEARCH_INDEX_NAME,  // ← Only searches parts_current!

Impact: Users won't see tire brand autocomplete suggestions

Fix: Use getAllSearchIndices() or detect tire context

4. MEDIUM: Real-Time Inventory Uses Raw Fetch

Current:

// real-time-inventory.tsx
const [data, setData] = useState<RealTimeInventoryData | null>(null);
const [isLoading, setIsLoading] = useState(true);
const [error, setError] = useState<string | null>(null);

const fetchInventory = useCallback(async () => {
  // Manual fetch, no caching, no retry
}, [partNumber]);

Best Practice (React Query):

const { data, isLoading, error, refetch } = useQuery({
  queryKey: ['tire-inventory', partNumber],
  queryFn: () => fetchTireInventory(partNumber),
  staleTime: 30 * 1000,  // 30 seconds
  retry: 2,
});

Benefits:

Automatic caching and deduplication
Built-in retry on failure
Background refetching
Better DevTools integration

5. MEDIUM: Zero Test Coverage

Missing tests:

app/tires/_lib/transform.test.ts       # Transform functions
app/tires/_components/*.test.tsx       # Component tests
lib/constants/manufacturers.test.ts    # Slug conversion
app/api/tires/inventory/route.test.ts  # API route

Recommendation: Add at minimum:

Unit tests for slug conversion functions
Unit tests for transformPartToTire
Integration test for tire detail page flow

6. LOW: Missing generateStaticParams

Current: All tire detail pages are dynamically rendered

Best Practice:

// app/tires/[slug]/page.tsx
export async function generateStaticParams() {
  // Pre-render top 100 popular tires for faster loads
  const tires = await getPopularTires(100);
  return tires.map((tire) => ({ slug: tire.slug }));
}

export const dynamicParams = true; // Allow dynamic for rest

7. LOW: console.error in Production

Files with console.error:

app/tires/error.tsx:16
app/tires/_components/real-time-inventory.tsx:155

Recommendation: Use structured logging or remove

Architecture Analysis

Data Flow Diagram

┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                         FRONTEND (CROP-front)                     │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                                                   │
│  /tires                          /tires/[slug]                    │
│     │                                 │                           │
│     ▼                                 ▼                           │
│  TiresCatalogClient              TireDetailPage                   │
│     │                                 │                           │
│     │ manufacturer=KMT                │ getPartBySlug(slug)       │
│     ▼                                 ▼                           │
│  searchServiceClient.searchParts()   searchServiceClient.getPart()│
│     │                                 │                           │
└─────┼─────────────────────────────────┼───────────────────────────┘
      │                                 │
      ▼                                 ▼
┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│                      BACKEND (CROP-parts-services)                │
├──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│                                                                   │
│  /api/search                     /api/parts/:id                   │
│     │                                 │                           │
│     ▼                                 ▼                           │
│  resolveSearchIndex()            getAllSearchIndices()            │
│     │                                 │                           │
│     │ manufacturer=KMT →              │ Returns both indices      │
│     │ → tires_current                 │ [parts_current,           │
│     │                                 │  tires_current]           │
│     ▼                                 ▼                           │
│  Elasticsearch Query              Elasticsearch Query             │
│                                                                   │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Index Resolution Logic

// services/search/src/utils/index-resolver.ts

resolveSearchIndex({
  manufacturer: "KMT",      // ← Matches TIRE_MANUFACTURER_CODES
  specBrand: "Michelin",    // ← Tire-specific filter
  specTireSize: "275/55R20" // ← Tire-specific filter
})
// → Returns: "tires_current"

getAllSearchIndices()
// → Returns: ["parts_current", "tires_current"]

Code Quality Analysis

Naming Consistency ✅

Pattern	Status
Files: kebab-case	✅ `tires-catalog-client.tsx`
Components: PascalCase	✅ `TireCard`, `TiresGrid`
Functions: camelCase	✅ `transformPartToTire`, `buildSearchParams`
Constants: UPPER_SNAKE	✅ `TIRE_MANUFACTURER`, `DEFAULT_PAGINATION`

Type Safety ✅

All components have proper TypeScript types
Zod schemas for API validation (backend)
No any types in tire code

Code Organization ✅

app/tires/
├── (catalog)/
│   ├── loading.tsx      # Catalog loading skeleton
│   └── page.tsx         # Server component, data fetching
├── [slug]/
│   ├── loading.tsx      # Detail loading skeleton
│   ├── not-found.tsx    # 404 page
│   └── page.tsx         # Server component, detail view
├── _components/
│   ├── tires-catalog-client.tsx  # Client component, filters
│   ├── real-time-inventory.tsx   # Live inventory check
│   └── types.ts                  # Type definitions
├── _lib/
│   └── transform.ts     # Data transformation
└── error.tsx            # Error boundary

Comparison with Best Practices

Next.js App Router

Best Practice	Status	Notes
Server Components for data fetching	✅	Catalog & detail pages
`revalidate` for caching	✅	60s configured
`loading.tsx` for streaming	✅	Skeleton UI
`error.tsx` for error boundary	✅	With retry
`not-found.tsx` for 404	✅	Clean UX
`generateStaticParams`	❌	Not implemented
`generateMetadata`	✅	OpenGraph, Twitter

React Query (TanStack Query)

Best Practice	Status	Notes
useQuery for data fetching	❌	Uses raw fetch
staleTime configuration	❌	No caching
Automatic retry	❌	No retry logic
Query invalidation	❌	Not applicable
Optimistic updates	N/A	Read-only

Elasticsearch Multi-Index

Best Practice	Status	Notes
Use index aliases	✅	`parts_current`, `tires_current`
Route by context	✅	`resolveSearchIndex()`
Cross-index lookup	✅	`getAllSearchIndices()`
Consistent slug format	❌	ES has old slugs

Improvement Plan

Phase 1: Critical Fixes (Deploy)

Task	Priority	Effort	Impact
Deploy search service	P0	10min	Tire pages work
Rebuild ES tires index	P0	20min	Slugs sync

# Step 1
gcloud run deploy search-service --source . --region us-east1 --project noted-bliss-466410-q6

# Step 2
bash services/search/scripts/gcp-rebuild-tires-index.sh

Phase 2: Quality Improvements (1-2 days)

Task	Priority	Effort	Impact
Fix autocomplete multi-index	P1	2h	Tire suggestions
Migrate to React Query	P1	4h	Better UX, caching
Add unit tests	P1	4h	Prevent regressions

Phase 3: Optimization (Optional)

Task	Priority	Effort	Impact
Add generateStaticParams	P2	1h	Faster popular pages
Remove console.error	P2	30min	Clean logs
Add structured logging	P3	2h	Better observability

Verification Checklist

After deploying:

# 1. Check new revision deployed
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/ready' | jq '.revision'
# Should be newer than "search-service-00310-mrr"

# 2. Test tire lookup by old slug (should work now)
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/api/parts/kmt-04493560000' | jq '.part.slug'
# Should return: "kmt-04493560000"

# 3. Test tire search
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/api/search?manufacturer=KMT&limit=1' | jq '.total'
# Should return: ~7091

# 4. Test frontend
open 'http://localhost:3000/tires/ct-kmt-04493560000'
# Should show tire detail page (with fallback to old slug)

After ES rebuild:

# 5. Verify new slug format in ES
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/api/search?manufacturer=KMT&limit=1' | jq '.parts[0].slug'
# Should return: "ct-kmt-04493560000"

# 6. Test frontend with new slug
curl 'https://api.crop-dev.app/api/parts/ct-kmt-04493560000' | jq '.part.slug'
# Should return: "ct-kmt-04493560000"

Summary

Category	Score	Status
Frontend Code Quality	90%	✅ Excellent
Backend Multi-Index	85%	✅ Good (autocomplete needs fix)
Deployment	0%	❌ Not deployed
Test Coverage	0%	❌ No tests
Documentation	80%	✅ Good
Overall	55%	⚠️ Blocked by deployment

Bottom Line: The code is well-written but not deployed. Once deployed and ES index rebuilt, tire pages will work. Then focus on React Query migration and test coverage.

Tire Implementation: Comprehensive Critical Review

On this page